Captain SeriesDon Mattingly

Tier 1 Tier 2 Tier 3

Requirements

Have 9 players that match the below criteria on your roster. You need to satisfy all requirements.

Players from the New York Yankees

Boosts

Contact Right

Batting Clutch

Hits Per Bf

K Per Bf

Starting Pitchers

Andy Pettitte

Hyper

99

OVR

Carlos Rodón

2024 Postseason

99

OVR

CC Sabathia

Hyper

99

OVR

Mike Mussina

Finest

99

OVR

Gerrit Cole

2024 Postseason

99

OVR

Show All

Relief Pitchers

Tommy Kahnle

2024 Postseason

99

OVR

Jonathan Loaisiga

Finest

98

OVR

Jose Trevino

Out of Position

95

OVR

Wade Boggs

Out of Position

95

OVR

Mariano Rivera

Breakout

93

OVR

Show All

Closing Pitchers

Luke Weaver

Season Awards

99

OVR

Rich Gossage

Hall of Fame

99

OVR

Andrew Miller

Finest

99

OVR

Mariano Rivera

Hall of Fame

99

OVR

Andrew Miller

Hyper

90

OVR

Show All

Catchers

Gary Sanchez

Awards

99

OVR

Austin Wells

2024 Postseason

99

OVR

Jorge Posada

Finest

99

OVR

Austin Wells

Topps Now

95

OVR

Gary Sánchez

Rookie

89

OVR

Show All

First Base

Austin Wells

2024 Postseason

99

OVR

Jorge Posada

Finest

99

OVR

D.J. LeMahieu

Hyper

99

OVR

Babe Ruth

Hall of Fame

99

OVR

Mickey Mantle

Hall of Fame

99

OVR

Show All

Second Base

D.J. LeMahieu

Hyper

99

OVR

Gleyber Torres

2024 Postseason

99

OVR

Anthony Volpe

2024 Postseason

99

OVR

Alfonso Soriano

Finest

99

OVR

Matt Carpenter

The Show Classics

98

OVR

Show All

Shortstop

Gleyber Torres

2024 Postseason

99

OVR

Derek Jeter

Hall of Fame

99

OVR

Anthony Volpe

2024 Postseason

99

OVR

Alfonso Soriano

Finest

99

OVR

Jazz Chisholm Jr.

Topps Now

98

OVR

Show All

Third Base

D.J. LeMahieu

Hyper

99

OVR

Gleyber Torres

2024 Postseason

99

OVR

Anthony Volpe

2024 Postseason

99

OVR

Alfonso Soriano

Finest

99

OVR

Matt Carpenter

The Show Classics

98

OVR

Show All

Left Field

Alex Verdugo

2024 Postseason

99

OVR

Juan Soto

2024 All-Star

99

OVR

Aaron Judge

Season Awards

99

OVR

Jasson Dominguez

Season Awards

99

OVR

Giancarlo Stanton

2024 Postseason

99

OVR

Show All

Center Field

Alex Verdugo

2024 Postseason

99

OVR

Juan Soto

2024 All-Star

99

OVR

Aaron Judge

Season Awards

99

OVR

Jasson Dominguez

Season Awards

99

OVR

Aaron Judge

2024 All-Star

99

OVR

Show All

Right Field

Alex Verdugo

2024 Postseason

99

OVR

Juan Soto

2024 All-Star

99

OVR

Aaron Judge

Season Awards

99

OVR

Jasson Dominguez

Season Awards

99

OVR

Giancarlo Stanton

2024 Postseason

99

OVR

Show All

ShowZone Newsletter

Stay up-to-date on everything MLB The Show.

Perfect-Perfect Grid Game

Play ShowZone's Perfect Perfect Grid. It's free & new ones daily!

ShowZone is a Video Game Numbers project. Not affiliated with Sony San Diego Studios or Major League Baseball.