Best Captain Cards in MLB The Show 26

60 captain cards ranked by ShowZone's 0-99 rating system.

1. Lee Smith (St. Louis Cardinals) — Rating: 99.0 — Eligible: Players from the St. Louis Cardinals
2. Hal Newhouser (Detroit Tigers) — Rating: 94.9 — Eligible: Players from the Detroit Tigers
3. Matt Carpenter (St. Louis Cardinals) — Rating: 94.2 — Eligible: Players from the St. Louis Cardinals
4. Cliff Lee (Seattle Mariners) — Rating: 91.4 — Eligible: Players from the Seattle Mariners
5. Hank Greenberg (Detroit Tigers) — Rating: 91.1 — Eligible: Players from the Detroit Tigers
6. Ubaldo Jiménez (Colorado Rockies) — Rating: 90.8 — Eligible: Players from the Colorado Rockies
7. Larry Walker (Colorado Rockies) — Rating: 87.4 — Eligible: Players from the Colorado Rockies
8. Mike Cameron (Seattle Mariners) — Rating: 85.2 — Eligible: Players from the Seattle Mariners
9. Rich Gossage (Chicago White Sox) — Rating: 78.5 — Eligible: Players from the Chicago White Sox
10. Darren O'Day (Baltimore Orioles) — Rating: 78.2 — Eligible: Players from the Baltimore Orioles
11. Rob Dibble (Cincinnati Reds) — Rating: 77.5 — Eligible: Players from the Cincinnati Reds
12. Billy Wagner (Houston Astros) — Rating: 77.5 — Eligible: Players from the Houston Astros
13. Al Leiter (Miami Marlins) — Rating: 77.0 — Eligible: Players from the Miami Marlins
14. Eric Gagne (Los Angeles Dodgers) — Rating: 76.3 — Eligible: Players from the Los Angeles Dodgers
15. Jason Giambi (Oakland Athletics) — Rating: 70.8 — Eligible: Players from the Athletics
16. Rafael Palmeiro (Texas Rangers) — Rating: 70.8 — Eligible: Players from the Texas Rangers
17. Fred McGriff (Tampa Bay Rays) — Rating: 70.6 — Eligible: Players from the Tampa Bay Rays
18. Mike Piazza (New York Mets) — Rating: 69.9 — Eligible: Players from the New York Mets
19. David Ortiz (Boston Red Sox) — Rating: 69.1 — Eligible: Players from the Boston Red Sox
20. Johan Santana (Minnesota Twins) — Rating: 68.2 — Eligible: Players from the Minnesota Twins
21. Pedro Martinez (Washington Nationals) — Rating: 67.5 — Eligible: Players from the Washington Nationals