Sign In Register GET PRO

Sign In Register GET PRO

PTierSummer — MLB The Show 26 Tier List

Tier list of MLB The Show 26 Diamond Dynasty cards created by kenji0910haru.

S-Tier (9)

2026 Draft Brody Bumila (96 OVR), SP
New Threads Tarik Skubal (99 OVR), SP
Signature Al Leiter (97 OVR), SP
2026 All-Star Jacob Misiorowski (99 OVR), SP
Spotlight Jacob Misiorowski (96 OVR), SP
Finest Billy Wagner (99 OVR), CP
Prime Jonathan Broxton (99 OVR), CP
Cityscapes Felix Bautista (92 OVR), CP
Mural Adrian Morejon (91 OVR), RP

A-Tier (9)

Milestone Johan Santana (99 OVR), SP
New Threads Dustin May (99 OVR), SP
All-Star Roger Clemens (97 OVR), SP
2026 All-Star Justin Verlander (97 OVR), SP
Spotlight Ranger Suarez (97 OVR), SP
2026 All-Star Mason Miller (97 OVR), CP
2026 All-Star Louis Varland (96 OVR), CP
New Threads Brooks Raley (98 OVR), RP
Finest Darren O'Day (96 OVR), RP

B-Tier (9)

Milestone Sandy Alcantara (97 OVR), SP
2026 All-Star Parker Messick (96 OVR), SP
Awards Felix Hernandez (99 OVR), SP
Spotlight Nolan McLean (98 OVR), SP
Finest Keith Foulke (99 OVR), CP
Milestone Jim Johnson (98 OVR), CP
2026 All-Star Jhoan Duran (98 OVR), CP
Spotlight Aaron Ashby (94 OVR), RP
Hall of Fame Trevor Hoffman (99 OVR), CP

C-Tier (14)

Field of Dreams Roy Halladay (99 OVR), SP
Spotlight Dustin May (96 OVR), SP
Spotlight Gavin Williams (99 OVR), SP
New Threads José Soriano (99 OVR), SP
Finest Roy Oswalt (99 OVR), SP
Spotlight Troy Melton (97 OVR), SP
Summer Rob Dibble (96 OVR), RP
2026 All-Star Jacob Latz (97 OVR), CP
Spotlight Mason Montgomery (97 OVR), RP
2026 All-Star Aroldis Chapman (98 OVR), CP
New Threads Huascar Brazobán (97 OVR), RP
2026 All-Star Riley O'Brien (96 OVR), CP
Spotlight Jordan Hicks (97 OVR), RP
New Threads Erik Miller (97 OVR), RP

MLB The Show 26 Tier List

PTierSummer

Created by kenji0910haru

S-Tier

Brody Bumila

Tarik Skubal

Al Leiter

Jacob Misiorowski

Jacob Misiorowski

Billy Wagner

Jonathan Broxton

Felix Bautista

Adrian Morejon

A-Tier

Johan Santana

Dustin May

Roger Clemens

Justin Verlander

Ranger Suarez

Mason Miller

Louis Varland

Brooks Raley

Darren O'Day

B-Tier

Sandy Alcantara

Parker Messick

Felix Hernandez

Nolan McLean

Keith Foulke

Jim Johnson

Jhoan Duran

Aaron Ashby

Trevor Hoffman

C-Tier

Roy Halladay

Dustin May

Gavin Williams

José Soriano

Roy Oswalt

Troy Melton

Rob Dibble

Jacob Latz

Mason Montgomery

Aroldis Chapman

Huascar Brazobán

Riley O'Brien

Jordan Hicks

Erik Miller

D-Tier

F-Tier

Best Gear for MLB The Show

We've found the best monitors, controllers, and more for MLB The Show.

Built for the MLB The Show community. Not affiliated with Sony San Diego Studios or Major League Baseball.

Discord Twitter Instagram YouTube TikTok

Top Content

What are the best Gaming Monitors for MLB The Show?
What are the best Controllers for MLB The Show?
What are the best Thumbstick Grips for MLB The Show?

Quick Links

Mobile App
Browser Extension
ShowZone Discord

Site Information

ShowZone Pro
Contact
Report an Issue
Privacy Policy

All Rights Reserved ©2026