Sign In Register GET PRO

Sign In Register GET PRO

TierSummer — MLB The Show 26 Tier List

Tier list of MLB The Show 26 Diamond Dynasty cards created by kenji0910haru.

S-Tier (6)

Hall of Fame Carlos Beltran (99 OVR), CF
Awards Victor Martinez (99 OVR), 1B
Milestone Troy Tulowitzki (99 OVR), SS
Signature Albert Pujols (99 OVR), 1B
New Threads Adley Rutschman (99 OVR), C
Signature Ken Singleton (99 OVR), RF

A-Tier (11)

Awards Geraldo Perdomo (99 OVR), SS
2026 All-Star Ozzie Albies (98 OVR), 2B
Hall of Fame Andruw Jones (99 OVR), CF
2026 All-Star Cody Bellinger (99 OVR), RF
Signature Ray Durham (99 OVR), 2B
2026 All-Star Juan Soto (98 OVR), LF
2026 All-Star Yordan Alvarez (99 OVR), LF
Spotlight Angel Genao (99 OVR), 3B
Milestone Jason Varitek (99 OVR), C
2026 All-Star Adley Rutschman (97 OVR), C
2026 Home Run Derby Kyle Schwarber (98 OVR), LF

B-Tier (12)

Spotlight Chipper Jones (94 OVR), 3B
Milestone Nolan Arenado (99 OVR), 3B
Milestone Miguel Cabrera (99 OVR), 3B
Awards Adrian Beltre (99 OVR), 3B
Awards Dustin Pedroia (99 OVR), 2B
Awards Willie McGee (99 OVR), CF
Vintage Ketel Marte (96 OVR), 2B
Milestone Stan Musial (99 OVR), LF
Postseason Lance Berkman (97 OVR), RF
2026 All-Star Bobby Witt Jr. (98 OVR), SS
2026 All-Star Mike Trout (99 OVR), CF
Pipeline Joshua Báez (99 OVR), CF

C-Tier (14)

Spotlight David Ortiz (99 OVR), 1B
Pipeline Max Clark (99 OVR), CF
Topps Now Luis Lara (96 OVR), RF
Pipeline George Lombard Jr. (99 OVR), SS
Spotlight Kazuma Okamoto (99 OVR), 3B
Cover Athletes Ernie Clement (99 OVR), 2B
Milestone Honus Wagner (99 OVR), CF
Milestone George Kell (99 OVR), 3B
Spotlight CJ Abrams (99 OVR), SS
Field of Dreams Kyle Schwarber (99 OVR), LF
Summer Willi Castro (96 OVR), 2B
Summer Cal Raleigh (98 OVR), C
Awards Jorge Posada (94 OVR), C
Prime Ted Simmons (96 OVR), C

MLB The Show 26 Tier List

TierSummer

Created by kenji0910haru

S-Tier

Carlos Beltran

Victor Martinez

Troy Tulowitzki

Albert Pujols

Adley Rutschman

Ken Singleton

A-Tier

Geraldo Perdomo

Ozzie Albies

Andruw Jones

Cody Bellinger

Ray Durham

Juan Soto

Yordan Alvarez

Angel Genao

Jason Varitek

Adley Rutschman

Kyle Schwarber

B-Tier

Chipper Jones

Nolan Arenado

Miguel Cabrera

Adrian Beltre

Dustin Pedroia

Willie McGee

Ketel Marte

Stan Musial

Lance Berkman

Bobby Witt Jr.

Mike Trout

Joshua Báez

C-Tier

David Ortiz

Max Clark

Luis Lara

George Lombard Jr.

Kazuma Okamoto

Ernie Clement

Honus Wagner

George Kell

CJ Abrams

Kyle Schwarber

Willi Castro

Jorge Posada

Ted Simmons

D-Tier

F-Tier

Best Gear for MLB The Show

We've found the best monitors, controllers, and more for MLB The Show.

Built for the MLB The Show community. Not affiliated with Sony San Diego Studios or Major League Baseball.

Discord Twitter Instagram YouTube TikTok

Top Content

What are the best Gaming Monitors for MLB The Show?
What are the best Controllers for MLB The Show?
What are the best Thumbstick Grips for MLB The Show?

Quick Links

Mobile App
Browser Extension
ShowZone Discord

Site Information

ShowZone Pro
Contact
Report an Issue
Privacy Policy

All Rights Reserved ©2026