Sign In
Register
GET PRO
Players
Market
Collections
Content
My Inventory
E-Books
More
Sign In
Register
GET PRO
Starting Pitchers — MLB The Show 26 Tier List
Tier list of MLB The Show 26 Diamond Dynasty cards created by OG_14.
GODSQUAD (5)
Spooky Randy Johnson (99 OVR), SP
Jolt Al Leiter (99 OVR), SP
Awards Greg Maddux (99 OVR), SP
Awards Cliff Lee (99 OVR), SP
Milestone Nolan Ryan (99 OVR), SP
S-Tier (15)
Milestone Corey Kluber (99 OVR), SP
Jolt Johan Santana (99 OVR), SP
Spooky Clay Buchholz (99 OVR), SP
Milestone Johan Santana (99 OVR), SP
Milestone Pedro Martinez (99 OVR), SP
The Negro Leagues John Donaldson (99 OVR), SP
2026 Finest Nolan McLean (99 OVR), SP
New Threads Dustin May (99 OVR), SP
World Baseball Classic Vance Worley (99 OVR), SP
World Baseball Classic James Paxton (99 OVR), SP
World Baseball Classic Hyun-Jin Ryu (99 OVR), SP
Awards Bob Gibson (99 OVR), SP
2026 Finest Zack Wheeler (99 OVR), SP
2026 Finest Yoshinobu Yamamoto (99 OVR), SP
Jolt Greg Maddux (99 OVR), SP
A-Tier (80)
Jolt Cliff Lee (99 OVR), SP
World Baseball Classic Ondrej Satoria (99 OVR), SP
2026 Postseason Jacob Misiorowski (99 OVR), SP
2026 Finest Payton Tolle (99 OVR), SP
2026 Finest Max Fried (99 OVR), SP
2026 Finest Parker Messick (99 OVR), SP
Pipeline Liam Doyle (99 OVR), SP
2026 Postseason Gavin Williams (99 OVR), SP
Milestone Anibal Sanchez (99 OVR), SP
2026 Finest Sean Burke (99 OVR), SP
2026 Finest Cam Schlittler (99 OVR), SP
2026 Finest Sonny Gray (99 OVR), SP
2026 Finest Dylan Cease (99 OVR), SP
Jolt Andy Pettitte (99 OVR), SP
Awards Andy Pettitte (99 OVR), SP
Jolt Corbin Burnes (99 OVR), SP
Milestone CC Sabathia (99 OVR), SP
Awards Felix Hernandez (99 OVR), SP
Spooky Kerry Wood (99 OVR), SP
2026 Finest Shohei Ohtani (99 OVR), SP
2026 Finest Logan Gilbert (99 OVR), SP
Awards Justin Verlander (99 OVR), SP
New Threads Tarik Skubal (99 OVR), SP
2026 Finest Drew Rasmussen (99 OVR), SP
Pipeline Ryan Sloan (99 OVR), SP
Signature Al Leiter (97 OVR), SP
2026 Finest Jesús Luzardo (99 OVR), SP
2026 Finest Shane Baz (99 OVR), SP
Jolt Jeff Suppan (99 OVR), SP
2026 All-Star Jacob Misiorowski (99 OVR), SP
Milestone Jered Weaver (99 OVR), SP
Milestone Garrett Crochet (99 OVR), SP
Spotlight Jacob deGrom (99 OVR), SP
Finest Jake Arrieta (99 OVR), SP
Jolt Pedro Martinez (99 OVR), SP
Jolt Roger Clemens (99 OVR), SP
Jolt Ubaldo Jiménez (99 OVR), SP
Jolt Jered Weaver (99 OVR), SP
Jolt Juan Marichal (99 OVR), SP
Jolt Corey Kluber (99 OVR), SP
Jolt Jake Arrieta (99 OVR), SP
2026 Finest Eduardo Rodriguez (99 OVR), SP
2026 Finest Michael Wacha (99 OVR), SP
Awards Tom Glavine (99 OVR), SP
Jolt Drew Rasmussen (99 OVR), SP
Jolt Yu Darvish (99 OVR), SP
Jolt Hal Newhouser (99 OVR), SP
Jolt Bert Blyleven (99 OVR), SP
Jolt Tom Seaver (99 OVR), SP
Jolt Vida Blue (99 OVR), SP
Jolt Gaylord Perry (99 OVR), SP
Jolt Steve Carlton (99 OVR), SP
Jolt CC Sabathia (99 OVR), SP
Cornerstone Max Scherzer (99 OVR), SP
Pipeline Kade Anderson (99 OVR), SP
Summer Tarik Skubal (98 OVR), SP
The Show Classics Logan Webb (99 OVR), SP
All-Star Roger Clemens (97 OVR), SP
Spotlight Dustin May (96 OVR), SP
2026 Draft Brody Bumila (96 OVR), SP
Spotlight Reid Detmers (99 OVR), SP
New Threads José Soriano (99 OVR), SP
Spotlight Troy Melton (97 OVR), SP
Spotlight Jacob Misiorowski (96 OVR), SP
Subway Mike Mussina (99 OVR), SP
Milestone Aaron Nola (99 OVR), SP
Spotlight Ranger Suarez (97 OVR), SP
2026 Finest Chris Sale (99 OVR), SP
Spotlight Andrew Alvarez (99 OVR), SP
Spotlight Cade Cavalli (99 OVR), SP
Pipeline Seth Hernandez (99 OVR), SP
2026 Topps Update Series Baseball Paul Skenes (99 OVR), SP
2026 Postseason Michael King (99 OVR), SP
2026 Postseason Gerrit Cole (99 OVR), SP
Field of Dreams Roy Halladay (99 OVR), SP
Spotlight Nolan McLean (98 OVR), SP
Spotlight Peter Lambert (98 OVR), SP
2026 Postseason Nick Martinez (99 OVR), SP
Spotlight Trevor Rogers (99 OVR), SP
Spotlight Bryan Woo (99 OVR), SP
B-Tier (40)
2026 Postseason Robert Gasser (99 OVR), SP
2026 Finest Cristopher Sánchez (99 OVR), SP
2026 Finest Walbert Ureña (99 OVR), SP
2026 Postseason Freddy Peralta (99 OVR), SP
Spotlight Connor Prielipp (99 OVR), SP
Spotlight Ryan Weathers (99 OVR), SP
New Threads Clay Holmes (98 OVR), SP
Awards Jeff Suppan (99 OVR), SP
Summer Hunter Greene (96 OVR), SP
Spotlight Gavin Williams (99 OVR), SP
Milestone Sandy Alcantara (97 OVR), SP
2026 All-Star Cam Schlittler (98 OVR), SP
Spotlight Ryan Johnson (99 OVR), SP
Spotlight Martín Pérez (99 OVR), SP
Pipeline Carlos Lagrange (98 OVR), SP
2026 Topps Update Series Baseball Chase Burns (99 OVR), SP
Topps Now Cole Ragans (97 OVR), SP
Pipeline Cam Caminiti (99 OVR), SP
New Threads Casey Mize (99 OVR), SP
New Threads Luis Castillo (97 OVR), SP
Pipeline Jamie Arnold (99 OVR), SP
The Negro Leagues Cool Papa Bell (99 OVR), SP
Milestone Dontrelle Willis (99 OVR), SP
Topps Now Matt Wilkinson (97 OVR), SP
Topps Now Zach Thornton (97 OVR), SP
Vintage Ubaldo Jiménez (95 OVR), SP
Milestone Jacob deGrom (95 OVR), SP
Standout Nolan Ryan (96 OVR), SP
2026 All-Star Chris Sale (97 OVR), SP
2026 All-Star Paul Skenes (98 OVR), SP
Spotlight Cal Quantrill (99 OVR), SP
Spotlight Jared Jones (97 OVR), SP
2026 All-Star Yoshinobu Yamamoto (98 OVR), SP
2026 All-Star Dylan Cease (98 OVR), SP
2026 All-Star Shohei Ohtani (99 OVR), SP
New Threads Connelly Early (98 OVR), SP
2026 Topps Update Series Baseball Trey Yesavage (99 OVR), SP
Pipeline Gage Wood (98 OVR), SP
Pipeline Tyler Bremner (98 OVR), SP
Pipeline Kendry Chourio (98 OVR), SP
C-Tier (36)
Jolt Dennis Eckersley (99 OVR), SP
2026 All-Star Parker Messick (96 OVR), SP
2026 All-Star Logan Webb (96 OVR), SP
Topps Now Noah Cameron (97 OVR), SP
Topps Now Mitch Bratt (97 OVR), SP
Finest Roy Oswalt (99 OVR), SP
All-Star Greg Maddux (96 OVR), SP
The Negro Leagues Peanut Johnson (99 OVR), SP
Topps Now Rhett Lowder (97 OVR), SP
Spotlight Foster Griffin (96 OVR), SP
2026 All-Star Jesús Luzardo (97 OVR), SP
Field of Dreams Whitey Ford (98 OVR), SP
2026 Draft Jackson Flora (98 OVR), SP
2026 All-Star Chase Burns (96 OVR), SP
2026 Draft Gio Rojas (97 OVR), SP
Spotlight Roki Sasaki (95 OVR), SP
Milestone Sonny Gray (96 OVR), SP
2026 All-Star Michael Wacha (96 OVR), SP
Summer Corey Kluber (95 OVR), SP
2026 All-Star Eduardo Rodriguez (95 OVR), SP
New Threads Robbie Ray (97 OVR), SP
All-Star Steve Carlton (96 OVR), SP
Topps Now Jackson Kent (97 OVR), SP
Topps Now Quinn Mathews (97 OVR), SP
The Negro Leagues Ted Radcliffe (99 OVR), SP
2026 All-Star Joe Ryan (95 OVR), SP
2026 Draft Cole Carlon (96 OVR), SP
The Negro Leagues Smokey Joe Williams (99 OVR), SP
2026 All-Star Nick Martinez (96 OVR), SP
Topps Now Taj Bradley (95 OVR), SP
2026 Draft Cameron Flukey (97 OVR), SP
2026 Draft Carson Bolemon (96 OVR), SP
2026 Draft Hunter Dietz (96 OVR), SP
2026 Draft Cade Townsend (96 OVR), SP
2026 Draft Tegan Kuhns (96 OVR), SP
2026 All-Star Justin Wrobleski (97 OVR), SP
F-Tier (18)
2026 All-Star Max Meyer (95 OVR), SP
Spooky J.R. Richard (99 OVR), SP
Topps Now Ian Seymour (96 OVR), SP
Spotlight Eury Pérez (97 OVR), SP
2026 All-Star Cristopher Sánchez (97 OVR), SP
2026 All-Star Justin Verlander (97 OVR), SP
Field of Dreams Robin Roberts (99 OVR), SP
Milestone Max Scherzer (96 OVR), SP
New Threads Kevin Gausman (97 OVR), SP
2026 Draft Logan Reddemann (96 OVR), SP
2026 Draft Liam Peterson (97 OVR), SP
2026 All-Star Drew Rasmussen (95 OVR), SP
Summer Nathan Eovaldi (95 OVR), SP
Spotlight Walker Buehler (95 OVR), SP
Cityscapes Trey Yesavage (96 OVR), SP
New Threads Freddy Peralta (97 OVR), SP
Spotlight Cristopher Sánchez (95 OVR), SP
Live Shohei Ohtani (95 OVR), SP
MLB The Show 26 Tier List
Starting Pitchers
Created by
OG_14
GODSQUAD
S-Tier
A-Tier
B-Tier
C-Tier
F-Tier