Sign In Register GET PRO

Starters ASG — MLB The Show 26 Tier List

Tier list of MLB The Show 26 Diamond Dynasty cards created by marcuskhaugen.

S-Tier (8)

Signature Al Leiter (97 OVR), SP
2026 All-Star Jacob Misiorowski (99 OVR), SP
2026 All-Star Yoshinobu Yamamoto (98 OVR), SP
Awards Felix Hernandez (99 OVR), SP
Summer Tarik Skubal (98 OVR), SP
All-Star Roger Clemens (97 OVR), SP
Spotlight Jacob Misiorowski (96 OVR), SP
2026 Draft Brody Bumila (96 OVR), SP

A-Tier (10)

Standout Nolan Ryan (96 OVR), SP
Spotlight Dustin May (96 OVR), SP
2026 All-Star Michael Wacha (96 OVR), SP
2026 All-Star Chris Sale (97 OVR), SP
Spotlight Ranger Suarez (97 OVR), SP
Milestone Sandy Alcantara (97 OVR), SP
2026 All-Star Justin Verlander (97 OVR), SP
2026 All-Star Parker Messick (96 OVR), SP
All-Star Greg Maddux (96 OVR), SP
2026 All-Star Justin Wrobleski (97 OVR), SP

B-Tier (25)

2026 Draft Tegan Kuhns (96 OVR), SP
2026 Draft Gio Rojas (97 OVR), SP
2026 All-Star Dylan Cease (98 OVR), SP
Spotlight Roki Sasaki (95 OVR), SP
2026 All-Star Jesús Luzardo (97 OVR), SP
Mural Payton Tolle (94 OVR), SP
Standout Andy Pettitte (94 OVR), SP
2026 Draft Cameron Flukey (97 OVR), SP
2026 Draft Cade Townsend (96 OVR), SP
2026 Draft Carson Bolemon (96 OVR), SP
2026 All-Star Cam Schlittler (98 OVR), SP
2026 All-Star Paul Skenes (98 OVR), SP
2026 Draft Cole Carlon (96 OVR), SP
Summer Hunter Greene (96 OVR), SP
Spotlight Foster Griffin (96 OVR), SP
Standout Anibal Sanchez (94 OVR), SP
Milestone Jacob deGrom (95 OVR), SP
2026 Draft Logan Reddemann (96 OVR), SP
Live Sonny Gray (78 OVR), SP
2026 All-Star Eduardo Rodriguez (95 OVR), SP
Mural Roy Halladay (94 OVR), SP
Vintage Ubaldo Jiménez (95 OVR), SP
All-Star Chris Sale (94 OVR), SP
Vintage Garrett Crochet (94 OVR), SP
2026 Draft Jackson Flora (98 OVR), SP

C-Tier (23)

2026 All-Star Drew Rasmussen (95 OVR), SP
Summer Nathan Eovaldi (95 OVR), SP
All-Star Steve Carlton (96 OVR), SP
Summer Corey Kluber (95 OVR), SP
2026 All-Star Max Meyer (95 OVR), SP
2026 All-Star Chase Burns (96 OVR), SP
Cityscapes Clay Buchholz (92 OVR), SP
Spotlight Davis Martin (94 OVR), SP
2026 Draft Hunter Dietz (96 OVR), SP
Spotlight Walker Buehler (95 OVR), SP
Breakout Corbin Burnes (94 OVR), SP
Spotlight Eury Pérez (97 OVR), SP
2nd Half Heroes Randy Johnson (92 OVR), SP
2026 All-Star Logan Webb (96 OVR), SP
2026 All-Star Nick Martinez (96 OVR), SP
The Negro Leagues John Donaldson (91 OVR), SP
2026 All-Star Joe Ryan (95 OVR), SP
2026 All-Star Cristopher Sánchez (97 OVR), SP
Milestone Max Scherzer (96 OVR), SP
2026 Draft Liam Peterson (97 OVR), SP
Topps Now Taj Bradley (95 OVR), SP
2026 All-Star Shohei Ohtani (99 OVR), SP
Spotlight Kyle Harrison (94 OVR), SP

D-Tier (11)

Spotlight Braxton Ashcraft (94 OVR), SP
Mural Bob Gibson (93 OVR), SP
Awards Max Fried (93 OVR), SP
Topps Now Kyle Freeland (94 OVR), SP
Milestone Kevin Gausman (93 OVR), SP
Spotlight José Soriano (93 OVR), SP
Summer Carlos Rodón (94 OVR), SP
Live Shohei Ohtani (95 OVR), SP
Cityscapes Trey Yesavage (96 OVR), SP
Mural CC Sabathia (92 OVR), SP
Cityscapes Bubba Chandler (94 OVR), SP

F-Tier (5)

Spotlight Chase Dollander (93 OVR), SP
2026 Draft Jared Grindlinger (97 OVR), SP
Spotlight Tatsuya Imai (94 OVR), SP
Vintage Luis Castillo (93 OVR), SP
2nd Half Heroes Jake Arrieta (93 OVR), SP

MLB The Show 26 Tier List

Starters ASG

Created by marcuskhaugen

S-Tier

Al Leiter

Jacob Misiorowski

Yoshinobu Yamamoto

Felix Hernandez

Tarik Skubal

Roger Clemens

Jacob Misiorowski

Brody Bumila

A-Tier

Nolan Ryan

Dustin May

Michael Wacha

Chris Sale

Ranger Suarez

Sandy Alcantara

Justin Verlander

Parker Messick

Greg Maddux

Justin Wrobleski

B-Tier

Tegan Kuhns

Gio Rojas

Dylan Cease

Roki Sasaki

Jesús Luzardo

Payton Tolle

Andy Pettitte

Cameron Flukey

Cade Townsend

Carson Bolemon

Cam Schlittler

Paul Skenes

Cole Carlon

Hunter Greene

Foster Griffin

Anibal Sanchez

Jacob deGrom

Logan Reddemann

Sonny Gray

Eduardo Rodriguez

Roy Halladay

Ubaldo Jiménez

Chris Sale

Garrett Crochet

Jackson Flora

C-Tier

Drew Rasmussen

Nathan Eovaldi

Steve Carlton

Corey Kluber

Max Meyer

Chase Burns

Clay Buchholz

Davis Martin

Hunter Dietz

Walker Buehler

Corbin Burnes

Eury Pérez

Randy Johnson

Logan Webb

Nick Martinez

John Donaldson

Joe Ryan

Cristopher Sánchez

Max Scherzer

Liam Peterson

Taj Bradley

Shohei Ohtani

Kyle Harrison

D-Tier

Braxton Ashcraft

Bob Gibson

Max Fried

Kyle Freeland

Kevin Gausman

José Soriano

Carlos Rodón

Shohei Ohtani

Trey Yesavage

CC Sabathia

Bubba Chandler

F-Tier

Chase Dollander

Jared Grindlinger

Tatsuya Imai

Luis Castillo

Jake Arrieta