Sign In Register GET PRO

Sign In Register GET PRO

Built for the MLB The Show community. Not affiliated with Sony San Diego Studios or Major League Baseball.

Discord Twitter Instagram YouTube TikTok

Top Content

What are the best Gaming Monitors for MLB The Show?
What are the best Controllers for MLB The Show?
What are the best Thumbstick Grips for MLB The Show?

Quick Links

Mobile App
Browser Extension
ShowZone Discord

Site Information

ShowZone Pro
Contact
Report an Issue
Privacy Policy

All Rights Reserved ©2026

Righty Pen ASG — MLB The Show 26 Tier List - ShowZone

Righty Pen ASG — MLB The Show 26 Tier List

Tier list of MLB The Show 26 Diamond Dynasty cards created by marcuskhaugen.

S-Tier (1)

Finest Darren O'Day (96 OVR), RP

A-Tier (3)

2026 All-Star Jhoan Duran (98 OVR), CP
2026 All-Star Mason Miller (97 OVR), CP
Summer Rob Dibble (96 OVR), RP

B-Tier (6)

Spotlight Cade Smith (95 OVR), CP
2026 All-Star Louis Varland (96 OVR), CP
Cityscapes Felix Bautista (92 OVR), CP
Cityscapes Rollie Fingers (91 OVR), CP
Summer Grant Taylor (94 OVR), RP
2026 All-Star Raisel Iglesias (96 OVR), CP

C-Tier (11)

2026 All-Star Riley O'Brien (96 OVR), CP
Spotlight Tejay Antone (95 OVR), RP
Standout Jonathan Broxton (94 OVR), CP
2nd Half Heroes Blake Treinen (90 OVR), RP
Spotlight Kenley Jansen (92 OVR), CP
Live Mason Miller (91 OVR), CP
Spotlight Jhoan Duran (91 OVR), CP
Topps Now Gabriel Hughes (95 OVR), CP
Topps Now Chad Dallas (93 OVR), RP
2026 All-Star Bryan Baker (95 OVR), CP
Topps Now Chase Petty (94 OVR), RP

D-Tier (5)

Spotlight Alimber Santa (93 OVR), RP
Mural Bruce Sutter (91 OVR), CP
Breakout Ryan Walker (92 OVR), RP
Jolt Eric Gagne (88 OVR), CP
Jolt Darren O'Day (88 OVR), RP

MLB The Show 26 Tier List

Righty Pen ASG

Created by marcuskhaugen

S-Tier

Darren O'Day

A-Tier

Jhoan Duran

Mason Miller

Rob Dibble

B-Tier

Cade Smith

Louis Varland

Felix Bautista

Rollie Fingers

Grant Taylor

Raisel Iglesias

C-Tier

Riley O'Brien

Tejay Antone

Jonathan Broxton

Blake Treinen

Kenley Jansen

Mason Miller

Jhoan Duran

Gabriel Hughes

Chad Dallas

Bryan Baker

Chase Petty

D-Tier

Alimber Santa

Bruce Sutter

Ryan Walker

Eric Gagne

Darren O'Day

F-Tier

Best Gear for MLB The Show

We've found the best monitors, controllers, and more for MLB The Show.