Best Catchers in MLB The Show 26

Top 25 list ranked by ShowZone's True Overall and Meta Overall ratings.

1. #1 Postseason Roy Campanella
2. #2 Awards Jorge Posada
3. #3 Cornerstone Salvador Perez
4. #4 Spotlight Shea Langeliers
5. #5 Postseason Victor Martinez
6. #6 2nd Half Heroes Rick Ferrell
7. #7 Cityscapes J.T. Realmuto
8. #8 The Negro Leagues Josh Gibson
9. #9 All-Star Adley Rutschman
10. #10 Spotlight Ben Rice
11. #11 Cityscapes Johnny Bench
12. #12 Live Cal Raleigh
13. #13 Topps Now Drew Romo
14. #14 The Negro Leagues Biz Mackey
15. #15 Spotlight Willson Contreras
16. #16 Egg Hunt Jason Varitek
17. #17 Spotlight Liam Hicks
18. #18 Topps Now Brandon Valenzuela
19. #19 All-Star Joe Mauer
20. #20 World Baseball Classic Will Smith
21. #21 Topps Now Samuel Basallo
22. #22 World Baseball Classic Austin Wells
23. #23 Topps Now Daniel Susac
24. #24 Spotlight Moisés Ballesteros
25. #25 All-Star Ivan Rodriguez