Sign InRegisterGET PRO
ShowZone
Sign InRegisterGET PRO
ShowZone Logo

Built for the MLB The Show community. Not affiliated with Sony San Diego Studios or Major League Baseball.

DiscordTwitterInstagramYouTubeTikTok

Top Content

  • What are the best Gaming Monitors for MLB The Show?
  • What are the best Controllers for MLB The Show?
  • What are the best Thumbstick Grips for MLB The Show?

Quick Links

  • Mobile App
  • Browser Extension
  • ShowZone Discord

Site Information

  • ShowZone Pro
  • Contact
  • Report an Issue
  • Privacy Policy

All Rights Reserved ©2026

Cornerstone Paul O'Neill is a 95 OVR Red Diamond RF card for the New York Yankees in MLB The Show 26. This ShowZone player page surfaces every attribute, equipped quirks, live marketplace buy and sell prices (refreshed every minute), ShowZone's proprietary True Overall™ and Meta Overall ratings, top-25 positional rankings, and recent real-life MLB performance. Compare cards side-by-side in the Player Compare tool or build a full Diamond Dynasty lineup in the Team Builder. Cornerstone Paul O'Neill is a 95 overall Red Diamond card in MLB The Show 26. Team: New York Yankees. Position: RF. Bats: Left. Throws: Left. True Overall™ Rating: 94.74 (best at DH). Meta Overall Rating: 92.42 (best at LF). Contact: 85L/113R. Power: 70L/83R. Vision: 96. Discipline: 77. Speed: 65. Fielding: 81. Arm: 80. Quirks (5): Homebody, First-Pitch Hitter, Dead Red, Situational Hitter, Night Player.

MLB The Show 26

Cornerstone PAUL O'NEILL

CORNERSTONE
RF|LF
L / LNEW YORK YANKEES
Updated Oct 8, 2026
Paul O'Neill Card
Height6'4"
Weight215 lbs
BirthplaceOhio
94.22
@
#329 Ranked
View Overall Data →
QUIRKS
Homebody
First-Pitch Hitter
Dead Red
Situational Hitter
Night Player
CAPTAINS
Derek Jeter
Andy Pettitte
LOCATION
  • Available on the reward path of the Paul O'Neill program (XP Reward Path - Step 5).
Advanced Data

Overall Ratings

Paul O'Neill's True Overall™ and Meta Overall ratings at every eligible position in MLB The Show 26.

OVERALL95
Left FieldSEC
93.78#345 Ranked
Center FieldOOP
91.56#436 Ranked
Right Field
94.22#329 Ranked
Designated HitterSEC
94.74#365 Ranked
Advanced Data

Player Ranks

Paul O'Neill's position among all cards for power, contact, pitching, baserunning, and versatility.

Power vs RHP#270
Contact vs RHP#60
Balanced vs RHP#151
Versatility#812
Baserunning#482
Packs

Find This Card in Packs

Loading pack data...

Frequently Asked Questions

Cornerstone Paul O'Neill inMLB The Show 26

Common questions about Paul O'Neill's card in MLB The Show 26.

You can find Cornerstone Paul O'Neill in the Paul O'Neill program reward path.

Cornerstone Paul O'Neill is a 95 overall Red Diamond card in MLB The Show 26.

Cornerstone Paul O'Neill has 5 quirks: Homebody, First-Pitch Hitter, Dead Red, Situational Hitter, Night Player.

Cornerstone Paul O'Neill has a Meta Overall rating of 92.42, ranking #285 at LF. The Meta Overall factors in the current game meta and how effective the player is in actual gameplay.
Data

Player Attributes

Detailed breakdown of Paul O'Neill's in-game attributes.

0
Contact99
Contact R
113
Contact L
85
Vision
96
Clutch
105
Power76
Power R
83
Power L
70
Fielding79
Ability
81
Forward
78
Backward
74
Right
82
Left
76
Speed67
Speed
65
Steal
72
Arm81
Arm Str
80
Arm Acc
85
Other30
Sac Bunt
35
Drag Bunt
25
Attribute Boosts

Player Quirks

Paul O'Neill has the following quirks that improve attributes in certain situations.

Homebody icon

Homebody

Performs better when playing at home
Player will receive an attribute boost during home games. The exact attributes are unknown, but an increase is PCI size has been documented.
View all players with this quirk
First-Pitch Hitter icon

First-Pitch Hitter

Excels at hitting the first pitch of an at-bat
Batting attributes receive a slight boost on the first pitch of an at-bat.
View all players with this quirk
Dead Red icon

Dead Red

Excels at hitting fastballs
Batting attributes receive a slight boost when a fastball is thrown.
View all players with this quirk
Situational Hitter icon

Situational Hitter

Excels at driving in a runner from third with less than 2 outs
Player will receive a batting attribute boost when there is a runner on third and less than two outs.
View all players with this quirk
Night Player icon

Night Player

Performs better when playing night games
Player will receive an attribute boost during night games. The exact attributes are unknown, but an increase is PCI size has been documented.
View all players with this quirk
Attribute Boosts

Eligible Captains

These captains can be used to boost this player's attributes.

Level:
Derek Jeter

Derek Jeter

Players from the New York Yankees
Cards Required: 15
CON L+6
CON R+6
PWR L+6
PWR R+6
Learn More About this Captain →
Andy Pettitte

Andy Pettitte

Players from the New York Yankees
Cards Required: 15
H/9 R+6
H/9 L+6
K/9 R+6
K/9 L+6
Learn More About this Captain →
Reviews

Player Reviews

Share your experience using Paul O'Neill in-game. How does the swing feel? Is the card worth the stubs? Help others decide if this card is right for their lineup.

Community Rating
0.0/ 5.0
Not yet rated
5
0
4
0
3
0
2
0
1
0

Sign in to rate this card and tell the community what you think.

Sign in
Real Life

Player Background

Paul O'Neill's real-life career history and accolades.

Full Name

Paul Andrew O'Neill

Nicknames

The Warrior

Birthplace

Columbus, OH

MLB Debut

1987

Jersey Numbers

#21

Draft History

Cincinnati RedsRd 41981

Education

Brookhaven HS (Columbus, OH)HS
Otterbein University (Westerville, OH)College

MLB Career

Cincinnati Reds1985-1992New York Yankees1993-2001

Awards

All-Star5
World Series5
Batting Champion
Xbox controller in grass

Best Gear for MLB The Show

We've found the best monitors, controllers, and more for MLB The Show.