Sign InRegisterGET PRO
ShowZone
Sign InRegisterGET PRO
ShowZone Logo

Built for the MLB The Show community. Not affiliated with Sony San Diego Studios or Major League Baseball.

DiscordTwitterInstagramYouTubeTikTok

Top Content

  • What are the best Gaming Monitors for MLB The Show?
  • What are the best Controllers for MLB The Show?
  • What are the best Thumbstick Grips for MLB The Show?

Quick Links

  • Mobile App
  • Browser Extension
  • ShowZone Discord

Site Information

  • ShowZone Pro
  • Contact
  • Report an Issue
  • Privacy Policy

All Rights Reserved ©2026

Mural Payton Tolle is a 94 OVR Diamond SP card for the Boston Red Sox in MLB The Show 26. This ShowZone player page surfaces every attribute, equipped quirks, pitch arsenal, live marketplace buy and sell prices (refreshed every minute), ShowZone's proprietary True Overall™ and Meta Overall ratings, top-25 positional rankings, and recent real-life MLB performance. Compare cards side-by-side in the Player Compare tool or build a full Diamond Dynasty lineup in the Team Builder. Mural Payton Tolle is a 94 overall Diamond card in MLB The Show 26. Team: Boston Red Sox. Position: SP. Bats: Left. Throws: Left. True Overall™ Rating: 94.46 (best at SP). Meta Overall Rating: 91.78 (best at SP). Velocity: 99. Control: 91. Movement: 95. H/9: null. K/9: null. BB/9: 91. Pitches: 4-Seam Fastball, Sinker, Cutter, Slurve, Circle Change. Quirks (3): Homebody, Night Player, Break Outlier. Market: Buy Now: 12,500 stubs. Sell Now: 17,998 stubs. Flip Profit: 3,698 stubs.

MLB The Show 26

Mural PAYTON TOLLE

MURAL
SP
L / LBOSTON RED SOX
Updated Oct 9, 2026
Payton Tolle Card
Height6'6"
Weight250 lbs
BirthplaceOklahoma
94.46
@
#139 Ranked
View Overall Data →
12,500
+1,185 (10.5%)
View Market Data →
QUIRKS
Homebody
Night Player
Break Outlier
CAPTAINS
David Ortiz
Dennis Eckersley
LOCATION
  • This card is available on the marketplace.
Advanced Data

Overall Ratings

Payton Tolle's True Overall™ and Meta Overall ratings at every eligible position in MLB The Show 26.

OVERALL94
Starting Pitcher
94.46#139 Ranked
Advanced Data

Player Ranks

Payton Tolle's position among all cards for power, contact, pitching, baserunning, and versatility.

5-Pitch Pitcher#131
4-Seam Fastball#142
Sinker#55
Cutter#58
Slurve#70
Circle Change#234
Packs

Find This Card in Packs

Loading pack data...

Frequently Asked Questions

Mural Payton Tolle inMLB The Show 26

Common questions about Payton Tolle's card in MLB The Show 26.

You can find Mural Payton Tolle in the Marketplace.

Mural Payton Tolle is a 94 overall Diamond card in MLB The Show 26.

Mural Payton Tolle currently has a Buy Now price of 12,500 stubs and a Sell Now price of 17,998 stubs on the Marketplace.

Mural Payton Tolle has 3 quirks: Homebody, Night Player, Break Outlier.

Mural Payton Tolle has a Meta Overall rating of 91.78, ranking #102 at SP. The Meta Overall factors in the current game meta and how effective the player is in actual gameplay.

ShowZone's live marketplace prices and True Overall + Meta Overall ratings give you the baseline — every card refreshes every minute. For deeper buy/sell signal, ShowZone Pro Diamond's Investment Intelligence tracks community buy/sell pressure on every card so you can see whether the broader community is loading up on Mural Payton Tolle or exiting. Pro Diamond also offers push price alerts so you can set a target buy price and get notified the moment Mural Payton Tolle hits it.
Data

Player Attributes

Detailed breakdown of Payton Tolle's in-game attributes.

0
Stuff90
H/9 vs R
105
H/9 vs L
93
K/9 vs R
98
K/9 vs L
60
Control
91
Clutch
90
Stamina
93
Fielding61
Ability
58
Arm61
Arm Acc
64
4-Seam Fastball

#142 Ranked

86

48% usage

VEL
96 mph
BRK
86
Sinker

#55 Ranked

96

24% usage

VEL
95 mph
BRK
95
Cutter

#58 Ranked

71

16% usage

VEL
89 mph
BRK
90
Slurve

#70 Ranked

70

9% usage

VEL
82 mph
BRK
62
Circle Change

#234 Ranked

68

3% usage

VEL
88 mph
BRK
65
Market Data

Market Analysis

Real-time market data and historical price trends for Payton Tolle.

Best Buy

12,500

+34(+0.3%)

Best Sell

17,998

-1,500(-10.3%)

BEST TIME TO BUY

Som 13pm

-896(-9.9%)

Pro

Profit/Min

87

Potential

Profit

3,698

After Tax

Profit %

29.58

After Tax

Sales/Min

0.05

Average 24h

Trading Times

Optimal Flipping Times

This feature is currently in beta. Best times to buy and sell based on data from the last 30 days. Upgrade to Pro to unlock.

Best Time to Buy

Superday 12-14pm PT
-9.9% (896)
9,053 → 8,154
Alternatives
Superday 12-14pm PT-8.7%
Superday 12-14pm PT-6.9%

Best Time to Sell

Superday 12-14pm PT
+10.2% (1,630)
15,982 → 17,605
Alternatives
Superday 12-14pm PT+8.1%
Superday 12-14pm PT+7.2%
Unlock with Pro
Price History

Historical Price Data

OHLC candlestick and volume charts for Payton Tolle.

Attribute Boosts

Player Quirks

Payton Tolle has the following quirks that improve attributes in certain situations.

Homebody icon

Homebody

Performs better when playing at home
Player will receive an attribute boost during home games. The exact attributes are unknown, but an increase is PCI size has been documented.
View all players with this quirk
Night Player icon

Night Player

Performs better when playing night games
Player will receive an attribute boost during night games. The exact attributes are unknown, but an increase is PCI size has been documented.
View all players with this quirk
Break Outlier icon

Break Outlier

Pitchers lose less break when tired
View all players with this quirk
Attribute Boosts

Eligible Captains

These captains can be used to boost this player's attributes.

Level:
David Ortiz

David Ortiz

Players from the Boston Red Sox
Cards Required: 15
CON L+6
CON R+6
PWR L+6
PWR R+6
Learn More About this Captain →
Dennis Eckersley

Dennis Eckersley

Players from the Boston Red Sox
Cards Required: 15
H/9 R+6
H/9 L+6
K/9 R+6
K/9 L+6
Learn More About this Captain →
Reviews

Player Reviews

Share your experience using Payton Tolle in-game. How does the swing feel? Is the card worth the stubs? Help others decide if this card is right for their lineup.

Community Rating
0.0/ 5.0
Not yet rated
5
0
4
0
3
0
2
0
1
0

Sign in to rate this card and tell the community what you think.

Sign in
Real Life

Player Background

Payton Tolle's real-life career history and accolades.

Full Name

Payton John Tolle

Birthplace

Stillwater, OK

MLB Debut

2026

Jersey Numbers

#70

Contract

Pre-Arb Eligible

Service Time

0.031 yrs

Draft History

Boston Red SoxRd 22024

Education

Texas Christian University (Fort Worth, TX)College
Wichita State University (Wichita, KS)College

MLB Career

Boston Red Sox2025-2026

Payton Tolle Stats — 2026 Season Pitching

GGSWLSVIPERERAWHIPK/9K/BB
2727970153.1512.991.1010.34.27
Xbox controller in grass

Best Gear for MLB The Show

We've found the best monitors, controllers, and more for MLB The Show.