The Best Derek Jeter Rookie Cards, Ranked

Derek Jeter, known as “The Captain,” remains one of the most iconic figures in baseball, beloved by fans for his leadership, work ethic, and undeniable talent. As he throws out the first pitch for Game 3 of the 2024 World Series in New York, it’s a perfect time to revisit some of Jeter’s most iconic rookie cards. His cards capture the early days of a Hall of Fame career, from rare inserts to flagship Topps releases. Here, we’ll cover the top Derek Jeter rookie cards, highlighting what makes each card unique and valuable to collectors.

 

Top Derek Jeter Rookie Cards to Add to Your Collection

1. 1993 SP Foil #279 (PSA 10 – $320,000, PSA 9 – $3,600)

The most iconic Jeter rookie card, the 1993 SP Foil, is also one of the most sought-after cards of the entire 1990s. Upper Deck introduced this premium product with a foil front, making it highly condition-sensitive. As a result, it has a shockingly low PSA 10 pop of only 22 out of over 49,000 graded copies. PSA 10s sell for around $320,000, while PSA 9s are far more affordable. For collectors seeking to own a piece of baseball history, this card is at the top of the list.

2. 1993 Upper Deck Gold Hologram #449 (PSA 10 – $3,000, PSA 9 – $390)

This rare version of Jeter’s Upper Deck rookie card was only available in factory sets, with a gold hologram on the back instead of the standard silver. Inserted in one of every 15 cases, it has an ultra-low PSA 10 pop of only 47. Despite a total graded pop of just 644, this card remains relatively affordable, making it a must-have for Jeter fans and collectors of rare 90s rookies.

3. 1993 Topps Micro #98 (PSA 10 – $2,700, PSA 9 – $50)

Issued only in factory sets, the 1993 Topps Micro is a miniaturized version of Jeter’s base Topps card. Centering and print issues make this card tough to grade, with only 61 gems across all graders. The unique size and scarcity make this card a fun addition to any Jeter collection, with a significant price in PSA 10 but affordable in PSA 9.

4. 1993 Topps Gold #98 (PSA 10 – $1,700, PSA 9 – $80)

The Topps Gold Jeter rookie offers an early parallel with a gold foil nameplate and ToppsGold logo. With only 3.8% of submissions achieving PSA 10 status, it’s relatively rare, pushing PSA 10 prices to nearly $2,000. However, this card remains accessible in lower grades, providing options for collectors of all levels.

5. 1993 Topps Inaugural Rockies & Marlins #98 (PSA 10 – $1,500, PSA 9 – $300)

These Topps Inaugural Rockies and Marlins cards commemorate the debut of these teams with a unique gold foil stamp. Produced in limited factory sets sold locally, these cards have small total populations, making them valuable in PSA 10 with around 100 gems for the Rockies and 200 for the Marlins. They’re a fun parallel for any Jeter rookie collection.

6. 1993 Pinnacle Series 2 #457 (PSA 10 – $500, PSA 9 – $32)

Released in Series 2, the 1993 Pinnacle Jeter card is known for its sharp black borders and glossy finish, both of which make it susceptible to chipping. With a pop of around 15,000 and a 9% gem rate, it’s difficult but not impossible to find in a PSA 10, driving the price up to around $500 in gem condition.

7. 1993 Stadium Club #117 (PSA 10 – $450, PSA 9 – $100)

Stadium Club cards are known for their high-quality imagery, and this Jeter rookie is no exception. Featuring a great shot of Jeter’s batting stance, this card is collectible due to its limited universal pop of about 8,300. The low pop count and high-quality image make this card one of the more valuable non-parallel Jeter rookies.

8. 1993 Bowman #511 (PSA 10 – $306, PSA 9 – $27)

Similar to the Pinnacle card, the Bowman Jeter has around 15,000 in total pop and a 9% gem rate. Its lower price could be due to the casual setting of Jeter fielding in a t-shirt. Still, it’s an affordable option for Jeter collectors in a PSA 10, and the Bowman branding adds appeal for rookie card enthusiasts.

9. 1993 Upper Deck #449 (PSA 10 – $300, PSA 9 – $30)

The standard version of Jeter’s Upper Deck rookie card, featuring a silver hologram instead of gold, was part of a “Top Prospect” subset in Series 2. With a 5% gem rate and universal pop around 24,000, this card remains popular and relatively accessible for collectors at $300 in a PSA 10.

10. 1993 Topps #98 (PSA 10 – $245, PSA 9 – $24)

The classic Topps base rookie for Jeter, this card has a massive universal pop of 75,000 but a lower gem rate of 7%. For those looking for an iconic and affordable Jeter rookie, this card is perfect, with PSA 10s priced around $245 and PSA 9s going for under $25.

11. 1993 Select #360 (PSA 10 – $175, PSA 9 – $22)

The 1993 Select Jeter features a memorable image of him jumping in Yankee pinstripes against a sky backdrop. With a limited pop around 9,000 and an 8% gem rate, it’s a bargain at $175 for a PSA 10, offering an iconic look and excellent value for Jeter collectors.

12. 1993 Score #489 (PSA 10 – $85, PSA 9 – $20)

The least popular of Jeter’s rookie cards, the 1993 Score card features a design that’s distinctly 90s with heavy graphics and frankly looks like it might’ve been made in Microsoft Word with WordArt. It has a 33% gem rate, making it easy to find in PSA 10 for under $100. Despite its affordability, it’s still a great option for a complete Jeter rookie collection.

 

Conclusion

Derek Jeter’s rookie cards capture the beginning of a Hall of Fame career that captivated baseball fans around the world. From the elusive 1993 SP Foil to classic Topps and Upper Deck releases, each card tells a part of Jeter’s story. Whether you’re a dedicated Yankees fan or a collector seeking a piece of baseball history, these cards offer a valuable way to celebrate “The Captain.”

 

Card images were provided by CardLadder.com.

---

This article contains affiliate links to products and services, including links from the eBay Partner Network (EPN). If you click on an affiliate link and make a purchase, we may earn a commission at no additional cost to you. Our relationship with EPN allows us to recommend products we believe will be of value to our readers. Thank you for your support.