JR Richards Houston Astros Mark McGwire St Louis Cardinals
MLB The Show NewsMLB The ShowDiamond DynastyMLB The Show 26

MLB The Show 26: Full Spooky Series Content Breakdown

Zad

Holiday festivities have kicked off in Diamond Dynasty inside MLB The Show 26, with this year's Spooky Program launching.

In years past, the Spooky Program has been a month-long jaunt through treats and goodies, delivered periodically with new Moments or missions in quick bursts. It appears we're getting the same layout, so this page will become our running one-stop to bookmark to stay updated on all new Spooky Program content.

As future cards are released in the program, you can find them here!

Spooky Program Breakdown

Part of the fun with the Spooky Program is the inclusion of premium packs along with the new cards. Plenty of us still haven't completed all the big Legends and Flashbacks collections, so getting free picks to circle back on what we still need is always great.

Two big-time power guys are the first two cards we can earn, with a power-pitcher and power-hitter setting the tone for Spooky month.

J.R. Richard is an absolute beast in terms of pure power and velocity. Outlier on his primary slider and secondary 4-seamer leaves hitters with no shortage of elite velocity to catch up to. Richard's pitch mix is rounded out with a cutter and sinker, with the cutter also nearing 100 MPH and the sinker being reliably mid-90s.

J.R. Richard is a classic dominant power pitcher that doesn't always translate to online play. The speed differentials are pretty close together, and upper divisions of online will most likely tee off on cards like this. However, in Events or lower divisions in Ranked, this is the type of card that you can fire off a random no-hitter with as well.

The second Spooky card reward in the program is Cardinals Big Mac.

Mark McGwire gets a St. Louis 99 OVR and immediately earns a spot on my squad somewhere. I will always love Sammy Sosa and Mark McGwire for making baseball fun in the 90s, as the great home run chase captivated 8-year-old Zad and helped grow my appreciation for the game. Getting to rock a McGwire card, clad in the 90's unis, will always be a great experience within MLB The Show for me.

Boy, does it make me smile that we get Slammin' Sammy directly after gushing over him and Mark McGwire's impact on baby Zad's childhood. This is nowhere close to the best Sammy we've seen, but it still makes me so happy that Big Mac and Sosa are in the game now.

Andrew Miller also dons the Spooky theme with his latest 99 OVR variant. Again, not the most premier version we've seen of Miller, but still plenty good enough to land inside the top-10 Meta Overall relievers. Miller still has elite attributes and his funky delivery, so a mighty-fine addition to any bullpen still wanting more lefty utility.

The Spooky Program's resident "boogeyman" turns out to be Jorge Polanco, revealed as the final reward.

Polanco is another Diamond Dynasty Darling, and often featured as a premium card. You'll have to knock out plenty of offline content to ultimately complete the Spooky Program and all of the cards featured, including Polanco, but you're also getting a Vault pack and plenty of other goodies.

Polanco himself is now the new #1 Meta Overall second baseman and shortstop, both of his eligible positions. Even more impressive is the fact that Polanco is also the new #1 Meta Overall first baseman, despite not having "official" eligibility at the position.

ShowZone recently debuted Out of Position, or OOP, rankings that highlight the hidden versatility of cards within Diamond Dynasty. Polanco's switch-hitting ability and overall offensive prowess elevate him significantly, as the out-of-position penalties keep him competitive with natural first basemen.

Read more about Out of Position rankings here, and learn how to get even more utility out of your collection.

Monster Smash Event Program Breakdown

A new Event has launched, offering up another Rewind pack, as well as Deluxe and Premier Choice Packs. Somewhat unexciting from a rewards standpoint, but a great way to continue stacking Premier and Ultra Choice packs in preparation for Finest.

We don't know for sure yet, but I would expect Finest to end up with the same tiered packs that we've gotten all year, meaning any Deluxe/Premier/Ultra Choice Packs you sit on could turn into a bunch of free Finest packs when they drop.

I personally prefer Events this time of year, as Ranked is played out and there's nothing new really going on. If you aren't chasing leaderboard status, Ranked sorta falls off by this time, so I'll take some Events and free packs.

Spooky Mini Seasons Breakdown

Brian Roberts Carlos Santana Clay Buchholz Gary Sheffield MLB The Show 26 Diamond Dynasty

A new Spooky Mini Seasons has also dropped, with four new card rewards along with plenty of packs and XP.

Carlos Santana is often a premium collection or Chase card, so getting access to one within a Mini Seasons run is a nice change. This is a 99 OVR Slamtana that does carry catcher eligibility, but looks strongest at 1B or DH to me.

Anytime we get an Atlanta Braves variant of Gary Sheffield, I am interested. This is prime Sheffield offensive prowess with ok enough defense to play in the field. He won't crack my main squad at this point, but boy does it make me want to bust out the Braves theme team again.

How To Exchange Spooky Variants In MLB The Show 26

SDS is trying something new, introducing an exchange to earn Spooky Variant packs. These packs feature what amount to "exchange vouchers", representing one of the previously released Spooky series cards.

Randy Johnson Seattle Mariners MLB

From there, you still need to own the actual card to complete the exchange. Collecting both the card and the variant voucher unlocks an alternate photonegative variation.

It's an interesting concept, with the exchange requiring five Red Diamond cards to earn a variant voucher pack. Interesting though it is, I don't really see much value in this outside of the rare few who already have every card in the game. If you're sitting on excess cards, even getting quick-sell Stub value seems more worthwhile than this exchange. MLB The Show was my dominant game all year, as always, and I still haven't completed the live series collection or gotten Ben Zobrist.

Then again, for those stepping away from the game soon, it's a fun way to get something unique. NBA 2K27 did something cooler with alternate card art, in my opinion, tying it to their PXP system (Player XP). Reaching a certain level unlocks the ability to choose from a set of variations, such as "holo" or "glass."

NBA 2k27 art style.webp

Alternate card art has always seemed like a no-brainer to me, so we've seen two different approaches this year. I much prefer getting the new style just by using the card, the best kind of replayability/gameplay loop a sports game can have. Exchanging five different cards, even if you can get them cheaply, for a slightly different art style with nothing else going on is just a little vanilla.

Chase Pack 32 Featuring 99 OVR Spooky Randy Johnson

Fittingly, our 99 OVR Randy Johnson sighting is by way of the Spooky series. The Big Unit is one of the spookiest arms you can imagine facing in the game, and this might be one of the few times a major name ending up as a Chase card is good for the betterment of mankind.

Theoretically, the exorbitant cost should make facing Johnson a rarity. And yet, fate will decide every time you queue into an online game for the rest of the game's cycle.

By the numbers, Spooky Randy Johnson doesn't land as the new top Meta starting pitcher. Landing at #8 instead, Johnson will still devastate most hitters you face online.

All MLB The Show 26 Spooky Series Cards Listed

Base Spooky Series cards

Spooky Variant cards (alternate art)

Bookmark this page and stay tuned for all future Spooky Program content drops, with card reviews and breakdowns as they are released!

Frequently Asked Questions

It is a month-long Halloween-themed program that releases new cards and premium packs in stages. You can bookmark the page for updates as new Moments and rewards drop.

The first rewards are 99 OVR J.R. Richard and Mark McGwire. Both are big power options that set the tone for the rest of the program.

It rewards a Rewind pack plus Deluxe and Premier Choice Packs. These Choice Packs can be saved for future premium sets like Finest.

Carlos Santana and Gary Sheffield are two of the featured 99 OVR rewards. Santana has catcher eligibility while Sheffield is a strong Braves theme-team option.

Yes, 99 OVR Spooky Jorge Polanco is currently the #1 Meta Overall second baseman and shortstop. He is also the #1 Meta Overall first baseman out of position thanks to his switch-hitting ability and strong offensive profile.

You exchange five Red Diamond cards to receive a Spooky Variant voucher pack, then pair the voucher with the actual base card to unlock the alternate photonegative art version. The system is optional and mainly useful for players who already own most of the cards or want unique cosmetic versions.

No, Spooky Variant cards are purely alternate art versions of the base Spooky Series cards and carry identical attributes. They are unlocked through the exchange system after you already own the regular version of the card.

Zad

Zad as an exclusive writer for ShowZone.

Comments

Sign in to join the conversation.

Sign in