The Headliners Set 4 pack has dropped in MLB The Show and it features a sneaky-good bullpen arm in Postseason David Robertson (87 OVR). While it’s not a top-tier flamethrower, this card fits a critical niche early in the Diamond Dynasty grind—especially for theme teams or those looking for a reliable middle relief option.
Pitch Mix Breakdown
David Robertson brings a five-pitch mix to the table:
- Cutter – 93 MPH
- Knuckle Curve – 85 MPH
- Slider – 84 MPH

This isn't an overpowering velo-hound, but a high-leverage shutdown arm. That lack of elite velocity is relevant, but Robertson possesses 85+ Break on each pitch including 99 Break on the Cutter.
For me, it certainly seems like breaking pitches have more depth this year. This is a good thing as it makes pitchers like this more usable and ultimately more valuable. The rather thin selection of relievers early in the year always makes a Diamond reliever a sought after commodity.
How Does He Play in the Meta?
According to ShowZone’s database, this version of Robertson holds a:
- Meta Overall: 80.49
- True Overall: 86.60
The Meta Overall suggests he isn’t a must-add to God Squads, but that True Overall rating shows he’s a strong bullpen option if you're lacking depth. His stamina and hits-per-9 (H/9) make him better suited for one-inning matchups or middle relief rather than as a closer. He thrives in situational roles—think runners on base, 6th inning, facing a tough righty.
A great addition to a Phillies' theme team, Robertson can find use in practically every bullpen right now.
Closing Thoughts
While not a meta-defining reliever, Postseason David Robertson is a versatile and effective arm who plays better than his 87 OVR suggests. He’s especially valuable for budget squads or theme builds and could become a low-key favorite for players who like to pitch strategically. Headliners keep settling around quick-sell value or not much higher, so this card should be fairly affordable over time.
Got a favorite bullpen sleeper so far this year? Let us know in the comments!
Zad
Zad as an exclusive writer for ShowZone.
More MLB The Show Talk

NOVEMBER 6, 2026
Mickey Mantle Rookie Card Value: 1951 Bowman, 1952 Topps and Every Early Mantle Card
Mickey Mantle's only true rookie card is the 1951 Bowman #253; the famous 1952 Topps #311 is his second-year card. Here's what both are worth at every grade, his other early cards, how many exist and how to spot reprints.

NOVEMBER 4, 2026
MLB The Show 26: All 2026 Finest Content Breakdown and Details
Finest 2026 is finally here, and we have a full breakdown of everything in the first batch. This page updates with each new release.

OCTOBER 29, 2026
Brewers Are World Series Champions: The Best HOMAGE Brewers Gear
The Brewers won their first World Series. Here's the best HOMAGE Brewers gear right now, from Contreras, Misiorowski and Chourio tees to '78 hoodies, plus HOMAGE's Championship Collection dropping November 12.
Comments
Sign in to join the conversation.
Sign in