The Fire & Finesse Program in MLB The Show 25 is a quick-run, pitcher-focused content drop centered around mastery of the mound. With a variety of moments and manageable stat missions, this program offers a pretty speedy path to rack up XP, rewards, and a strong rotation arm in 90 overall Dustin May.
Pitching Moments with Personality
The backbone of this program is a set of pitching-exclusive Moments totaling 33 stars. Each Moment comes with a little extra flavor as they feature prominent pitchers paired with their signature pitch.
Stat Missions – Stackable & Strategic
Beyond the Moments, the stat grind is both team-based and role-specific. Each mission is worth 3 stars, with 27 total stars available. Here's the breakdown:
- 10 IP with RHP
- 10 IP with LHP
- 5 IP with RP
- 5 IP with CP
- 15 Ks with RP
- 15 Ks with CP
- 10 IP with any Dodgers pitcher
- 1 Win with Dodgers pitcher (any DD mode)
- 750 PXP with any Dodgers player
Pro Tip:
Load up a full Dodgers squad in Play vs CPU on Rookie difficulty. This allows you to grind innings, rack up PXP, and secure a win—all in one outing.
Total Completion Strategy
You only need 50 stars to complete the program. With 33 stars from Moments and 27 stars from missions, you've got room to skip some Moments or start mission grinds instead. It’s a flexible setup that allows you to complete the program depending on how you see fit.
Topps Now SP Dustin May (Los Angeles Dodgers)

We often talk about hitters with sweet swings, and this Dustin May is an example of a pitcher with a sweet pitch mix. Featuring an Outlier Sinker with 99 Break, a 100 MPH 4-Seamer and a Cutter/Sweeper pairing topped off with a Circle-Change; May arguably has the "perfect" competitive pitch-mix minus an Outlier 4-Seamer.
The speed differential between Mays' repertoire is notable, but the significant velocities and movement should help you navigate against most hitters. Really good hitters will always hit well against any pitcher, but May has the template that can be successful against most players.
Once you've completed the 50-star milestone, you'll earn:
- 90 Overall Topps Now Dustin May
- 25,000 XP
- 3 Show Packs
- 250 Stubs
A tidy reward haul for what’s essentially a pitching skills showcase. There's some meme flavor here if we squint, as May releasing a couple days before "it's gonna be May" can warm even the coldest millennial's heart.
Zad
Zad as an exclusive writer for ShowZone.
More MLB The Show Talk

NOVEMBER 17, 2026
HOMAGE Black Friday and Cyber Monday 2026: Up to 40% Off and $125 Starter Jackets
HOMAGE's Black Friday sale (Nov. 23–27) takes 25% off sitewide, and Cyber Monday (Nov. 28–Dec. 1) goes up to 40% off with 30% off Starter jackets. Here are the dates, the STARTER20 code and our picks: MLB Starter jackets, MLB The Show tees, Topps hoodies and NFL Blackout jackets.

NOVEMBER 14, 2026
All-Time Teams Program Parties Like It's 2019
The All-Time Teams Program highlights MLB The Show's staleness, even with an Extreme version featuring alternate card art.

NOVEMBER 11, 2026
November Meta & True Overall Update: Hitters Close the Gap
Our November tuning: with Finest and Postseason taking over lineups, starting pitchers come down and hitters climb the Meta Overall top 25. Here's what changed.
Comments
Sign in to join the conversation.
Sign in