MLB The Show 24: All Legends Listed

Legends are a huge part of any sports game. While it’s a blast to use current-day players, diving into nostalgia with our favorite childhood players or historical players is a huge part of the experience.

MLB The Show 24 features over 190+ legends and we’ve compiled a list of the legends currently known.

Keep in mind we’ll probably get a couple surprise reveals throughout the year in Diamond Dynasty, as SDS routinely saves a couple “hidden legends” for the in-season content cycle.

Returning Legends

Roy Halladay

Mike Mussina

Randy Johnson

Pedro Martinez

Greg Maddux

Tom Glavine

Mariano Rivera

Billy Wagner

Brian Wilson

Robb Nen

Trevor Hoffman

John Smoltz

Derek Jeter

Mark McGwire

David Ortiz

Larry Walker

Ryan Braun

Joe Mauer

Chase Utley

Ivan Rodriguez

Frank Thomas

Chipper Jones

Vladimir Guerrero

Sammy Sosa

Ian Kinsler

David Wright

Alex Gordon

Matt Holliday

Tim Raines

Mike Cameron

Ryan Ludwick

Rickey Henderson

Tony Gwynn

Ken Griffey Jr.

Mike Schmidt

Jim Thome

Eddie Murray

Mike Piazza

Cal Ripken Jr.

Joe Morgan

Gary Carter

Craig Biggio

George Brett

Andre Dawson

Jeff Bagwell

Orlando Cepeda

Rod Carew

Wade Boggs

Paul Molitor

Ozzie Smith

Robin Yount

Greg Vaughn

Catfish Hunter

Bret Saberhagen

Don Sutton

Tom Seaver

Nolan Ryan

Vida Blue

Ron Guidry

John Franco

Tom Henke

Bruce Sutter

Rich Gossage

Lee Smith

J.R. Richard

Fernando Valenzuela

Jim Palmer

Dennis Eckersley

Jackie Robinson

Mickey Mantle

Willie Mays

Hank Aaron

Lou Gehrig

Ernie Banks

Ralph Kiner

Eddie Mathews

Johnny Bench

Buck O’Neil

Honus Wagner

Duke Snider

Roberto Clemente

Joe Torre

Harmon Killebrew

Stan Musial

Brooks Robinson

Larry Doby

Hank Thompson

Martin Dihigo

Rube Foster

Phil Niekro

Robin Roberts

Hilton Smith

Bob Feller

Juan Marichal

Whitey Ford

Babe Ruth

John Donaldson

Fergie Jenkins

Hal Newhouser

Cy Young

Satchel Paige

Bob Gibson

Warren Spahn

Rollie Fingers

Jim Edmonds

Gary Sheffield

Bert Blyleven

Alan Trammell

Eric Davis

Todd Helton

Edgar Martinez

Willie McCovey

Luis Gonzalez

Willie Stargell

Al Kaline

Jason Giambi

Grady Sizemore

Barry Larkin

Tony Perez

Troy Glaus

Eric Gagne

Carlos Delgado

Don Mattingly

Ryne Sandberg

Dante Bichette

Curtis Granderson

Prince Fielder

Ryan Howard

David Justice

Monte Irvin

Jimmy Rollins

Cliff Lee

Minnie Minoso

Billy Williams

Jorge Posada

Justin Morneau

Paul Konerko

Kevin Youkilis

Rob Dibble

Torii Hunter

Steve Finley

Johnny Damon

Vinny Castilla

Matt Cain

Alfonso Soriano

Roy Oswalt

Kerry Wood

A.J. Burnett

Harold Baines

Jason Bay

Joe Nathan

Michael Young

Brandon Webb

Brian Roberts

Richie Ashburn

Bill Mazeroski

Jim Rice

Lou Brock

Dontrelle Willis

Al Leiter

Adam Dunn

Mike Napoli

Mark Prior

Troy Percival

Tim Salmon

Luis Aparicio

Tony Clark

Mike Lowell

Carlos Pena

Ken Griffey Sr.

Kyle Seager

Chili Davis

Jerry Hairston Jr.

Raul Ibanez

New Legends

Andy Pettitte

Johan Santana

Andrew Miller

Bernie Williams

Adrian Beltre

Richie Sexson

Brian Dozier

Rich Aurilia

Tony Tarasco

John Kruk

Rafael Palmeiro

Paul O’Neill

Josh Gibson

Buck Leonard

Toni Stone

Tony Oliva

There’s the full list of legends in MLB The Show 24. Who is your favorite legend in this year’s game? What legends do you want to see added in the future?