Sign InRegisterGET PRO
ShowZone
Sign InRegisterGET PRO
ShowZone Logo

Built for the MLB The Show community. Not affiliated with Sony San Diego Studios or Major League Baseball.

DiscordTwitterInstagramYouTubeTikTok

Top Content

  • What are the best Gaming Monitors for MLB The Show?
  • What are the best Controllers for MLB The Show?
  • What are the best Thumbstick Grips for MLB The Show?

Quick Links

  • Mobile App
  • Browser Extension
  • ShowZone Discord

Site Information

  • ShowZone Pro
  • Contact
  • Report an Issue
  • Privacy Policy

All Rights Reserved ©2026

Meta Overall Update #3 – Pitch Arsenal and Hitter Balance
Meta OverallMLB The Show News

Meta Overall Update #3 – Pitch Arsenal and Hitter Balance

Corey
July 1, 2023

We are thrilled to bring you the first major update to Meta Overall in the MLB The Show 23 game cycle and our third overall update to the algorithm. This update represents our commitment to provide a dynamic, accurate, and engaging rating system that evolves alongside the game’s meta.

See the previous Meta Overall update summary articles here:

Meta Overall Update #2 – Hitting

Meta Overall Update #1 – Pitch Tunneling

Key Updates

Pitchers

We’ve taken the mound to make some essential changes to our pitchers:

  1. We’ve elevated the importance of BB/9, bridging the gap with H/9 and K/9. This should better reflect the significance of pitch control in this year’s game.
  2. We’re now varying the Meta Overall for pitchers based on their pitch arsenal. Pitchers with 5 different pitches now gain a slight boost, while those with only 3 pitches see a minor decrease.
  3. With the introduction of additional quirks this year, we’ve fine-tuned the structure of quirks boosts, opening up even more strategic options for players.

Hitters

At the plate, we’ve also made several substantial adjustments:

  1. We’ve rebalanced the scales between power and contact while shifting some weight from less crucial fielding metrics to hitting, aligning more closely with how players are currently utilizing hitting-focused cards.
  2. The Meta Overall for Shortstops has undergone a significant revamp. While previous metas favored high-speed, high-power players, this season has seen the rise of alternatives like Incognito Brandon Crawford and Kaiju Corey Seager.
  3. With changes to the throwing mechanics this year, we’ve shuffled fielding attributes’ importance, emphasizing the fielding attribute itself and arm accuracy. Of course, 1st base remains dominated by fielding ability itself due to the crucial need of catching potentially off-target throws.

Top Players Post-Update

Post-update, the Meta Overall landscape has shifted, resulting in a new crop of top-performing players. Let’s take a look at who are now the cream of the crop, listed at their highest rated Meta Overall position (including secondary penalties):

  1. 99 Kaiju Joe Mauer at C (115.97)
  2. 99 Incognito Mickey Mantle in LF (115.05)
  3. 99 Finest Chipper Jones at 3B (114.63)
  4. 99 Milestone Babe Ruth at 1B (114.56)
  5. 99 Incognito Hank Aaron in LF (114.07)
  6. 99 Incognito Stan Musial at 1B (112.93)
  7. 99 Kaiju David Wright at 3B (112.37)
  8. 99 Monthly Awards Aaron Judge in LF (110.70)
  9. 99 Awards Sammy Sosa in LF (110.50)
  10. 99 WBC Shohei Ohtani in LF (109.80)

The Best Lineup

With these updates, the optimal lineup to leverage the current meta looks a little different. Check out the images below to see the most impactful lineup based on the updated Meta Overall.

MO-Roster.png
MO-Roster-Pitching.png

Conclusion

This update reflects our commitment to adapt Meta Overall alongside the evolving game meta of MLB The Show 23. In our next update, we aim to refine and improve on these changes even further.

As always, your feedback is crucial in this continuous improvement process. We welcome any suggestions or thoughts you may have on these updates. Feel free to reach out to us on Twitter, Instagram, Facebook, or email us at team@showzone.io.Let’s shape the future of MLB The Show together!

Corey

Corey founded ShowZone in 2019, originally running it from a Raspberry Pi in his office while working as an engineer in the power industry. He taught himself to code in order to build and maintain ShowZone alongside the day job - managing energy deals on one screen and Diamond Dynasty market data on the other.

More MLB The Show Talk

Comments

Sign in to join the conversation.

Sign in
Xbox controller in grass

Best Gear for MLB The Show

We've found the best monitors, controllers, and more for MLB The Show.

MLB The Show 26: New Multiplayer Program and Ranked Rewards

OCTOBER 28, 2026

MLB The Show 26: New Multiplayer Program and Ranked Rewards

For those venturing into online territory, a new season of Ranked begins with a new Multiplayer program. Full breakdown here.

ShowZone Is Officially Partnered With HOMAGE

OCTOBER 28, 2026

ShowZone Is Officially Partnered With HOMAGE

ShowZone is now officially partnered with HOMAGE, the Columbus apparel company and official apparel partner of MLB The Show. Here's why, where you'll see HOMAGE across ShowZone and what it means for you.

HOMAGE Review: Sizing, Quality and 17 Years of Wearing It

OCTOBER 28, 2026

HOMAGE Review: Sizing, Quality and 17 Years of Wearing It

An honest HOMAGE review from someone who's worn it since 2008: how HOMAGE tees, hoodies and hats fit, whether they shrink, and how they hold up after years of wear, with photos of new and 15-year-old pieces.