How to Choose Your Team Jersey Look and Feel in MLB The Show

Your jersey in MLB The Show is more than just fabric and logos—it's your squad's first impression, your statement of style, and, let’s be honest, a core part of the vibe when you're cooking with a God Squad. Whether you're repping a full theme team or just want a clean aesthetic for your Diamond Dynasty lineup, here's how to dial in the perfect look.

Pick a Theme and Stick With It

Start with the foundation. Are you building around a team—like an all-time Yankees squad? A country—maybe a Team USA look? Or are you just going full custom with vibes only? Commit to a theme early on, and your jersey choices (color scheme, logo style, font, etc.) will fall into place much easier.

There's plenty of random colors that match well, so it will come down to your pure self-expression. Sounds scary! But remember that no one sees your uniforms more than you, so create something you enjoy looking at.

Match Your Colors to the Card Art

This is low-key elite. Matching your team’s home and away jerseys to the dominant colors in your squad’s card art creates a cohesive aesthetic that makes highlight reels hit harder. It’s that little detail that separates the casuals from the demons.

Sure, this can get difficult if you have different card series on your squad. Perhaps a more focused version of this is a Parallel Squad. If you have a team full of P5 players, matching that fiery blue with your jerseys could really make your team pop.

Experiment With Fonts and Logos

Don’t sleep on fonts. MLB The Show gives you a wide variety of styles—from retro block letters to edgy modern scripts. Combine fonts with custom logos (or upload your own if you’re on PS5/Xbox) to really make it your team. Keep it readable, but don’t be afraid to get bold—Diamond Dynasty is your playground. Don't forget about our logo services to take care of the heavy lifting.

Alternate Uniforms? Go for It

Create multiple uniform sets for home and away games, or even add an alternate Sunday drip. Keep some cohesion across the sets, but let one set be your flashiest. You’ve got to have that one jersey that makes your opponent say, “Okay, that’s fire.”

Back in my prime gaming days with Tiger Woods PGA Tour 2005, I bought enough outfit combinations to change my golfer's attire for every round. Yes, that included a special Sunday outfit. There's absolutely nothing stopping you from doing the same in MLB The Show 25.

It'll take a little extra work if you want to swap them regularly, but at least having the design in mind can lead to a quick turnaround of swapping designs.

Got a jersey combo that’s turning heads? Let us know in the comments!