Chase Utley got 59.1% of the Hall of Fame vote in January 2026, up from 39.8% the year before, and a jump like that usually means a player gets in soon. He needs 75% on the 2027 ballot, and many projections have him getting there. The six-time All-Star was the best second baseman of his era and a big part of the Phillies' 2008 World Series title. Here are his best rookie and prospect cards and what they sell for now.
Prices updated October 2026. Each figure is the average of the card's three most recent PSA-graded sales tracked by Card Ladder, or its most recent sale where fewer exist. Population counts are from GemRate as of October 2026.
Utley's rookie-era market is smaller than Posey's: most of his early parallels trade raw or in BGS slabs, so several prices below are recent sales rather than PSA 10 averages.
Quick Picks
- Best rookie card: 2001 Bowman Draft Picks & Prospects #BDP69 (about $850 in PSA 10)
- Most valuable early parallel: 2002 Bowman Chrome #241 Gold Refractor /50 ($680 to $1,250)
- Best value rookie: 2001 Bowman Heritage #304 (about $290 in PSA 10)
- First autograph: 2002 Bowman Autographs #BA-CU (about $110 raw)
The Best Chase Utley Rookie Cards
1. 2001 Bowman Draft Picks & Prospects #BDP69 (PSA 10 – $850, PSA 9 – $140)
This is Utley's true rookie card, and it's the one the market cares about. It was only sold in factory sets, a year after the Phillies drafted him 15th overall out of UCLA in 2000. PSA 10s have sold for $650 to $1,050 over the past year, and with only 150 PSA 10s out of 1,219 graded, gem copies don't come up often.
2. 2002 Bowman Chrome #241 Gold Refractor /50 ($680 to $1,250 in 2026, mostly BGS)
The Gold Refractor of his first Bowman Chrome card is numbered to 50 and is his most valuable early parallel. It trades mostly in BGS slabs: BGS 8.5 copies sold for $1,150 and $1,250 in June 2026.
3. 2003 Topps Chrome #438 X-Fractor /57 (with Gavin Floyd) ($615 to $809 in 2026, top sale $1,300)
Utley shares this Topps Chrome prospect card with fellow Phillies prospect Gavin Floyd. The X-Fractor is numbered to 57, and copies have sold for $615 to $809 this year, with a high of $1,300 in 2024.
4. 2003 Topps Chrome #438 Black Refractor /199 (with Gavin Floyd) ($585, June 2026 sale)
The Black Refractor of the same dual-player card is numbered to 199 and sold for $585 in June 2026. It's a cheaper way into his scarce Chrome parallels.
5. 2002 Bowman Chrome #241 X-Fractor /250 (PSA 8 – $400, August 2026 sale)
Numbered to 250, the X-Fractor sits between the Gold and the base Refractor. Two copies sold for $400 this summer, one in a PSA 8 and one raw.
Chase Utley Shirts
Men's Nike Chase Utley Red Philadelphia Phillies Wall of Fame T-Shirt
$26.99Shop at Fanatics →
Men's Mitchell & Ness Chase Utley Black Philadelphia Phillies Legendary Collage Player T-Shirt
$28.79Shop at Fanatics →
Men's Nike Chase Utley Royal Philadelphia Phillies Wall of Fame Name & Number T-Shirt
$29.99Shop at Fanatics →
Men's Nike Chase Utley Red Philadelphia Phillies Wall of Fame Name & Number T-Shirt
$32.49Shop at Fanatics →
Live Fanatics prices, updated automatically.
Chase Utley Jerseys
Men's Mitchell & Ness Chase Utley White Philadelphia Phillies 2003 Cooperstown Collection Authentic Jersey
$210Shop at Fanatics →
Chase Utley Philadelphia Phillies Autographed White Nike Replica Jersey
$399.99Shop at Fanatics →
Live Fanatics prices, updated automatically.
6. 2002 Bowman Chrome #241 Refractor /500 (PSA 9 – $430, February 2026 sale)
The base Refractor is numbered to 500. No PSA 10 has sold publicly, and a PSA 9 brought $431 in February. Raw copies sell for $145 to $270.
7. 2001 Bowman Heritage #304 (PSA 10 – $290, PSA 9 – $125)
His other true rookie card. PSA 10s are steady at about $285, which makes it the most affordable gem-grade Utley rookie.
8. 2002 Bowman Chrome #241 (PSA 10 – $240, PSA 9 – $75)
Utley's first Chrome card is technically a pre-rookie by today's rules, but it's one of his most collected cards and the base version of the parallels above. Only 47 PSA 10s exist.
9. 2002 Bowman Autographs #BA-CU (raw – $110, October 2026 sale)
His first certified autograph trades mostly raw, at $95 to $165. A CGC Auto 10 sold for $207 in September, and no PSA 10 sale is on record.
10. 2001 Bowman Draft Picks & Prospects Futures Game Relics #FGR-CU (PSA 9 – $128, August 2026 sale)
A rookie-year relic card from the same set as his true rookie, featuring a piece of a Futures Game jersey. Raw copies cost $25 to $40.
Beyond the Rookies
Utley's highest sales overall are modern cards: one-of-one patches, bat knobs and multi-player autographs from 2008 to 2026, which can sell for thousands. They aren't rookie cards, but they're worth watching if he's elected.
Utley is also in MLB The Show 26: see his 94 Vintage card. Shopping for a Phillies fan? See our Phillies gift guide.
Card images courtesy of Card Ladder and GemRate.
This article contains affiliate links, including links from the eBay Partner Network. If you buy through one of them, ShowZone may earn a commission at no additional cost to you.
