Top Rookie Cards · MLB The Show 26
8 cards · ranked by Meta Overall
Cards representing a player's first MLB season, rated to that debut year's performance. Rookie of the Year winners often produce the strongest entries.
333 Cards·9 MLB The Show Years·Ranked by Meta Overall
8 cards · ranked by Meta Overall
15 cards · ranked by Meta Overall
Mike Trout
98 META·CF·LAA
Devin Williams
90 META·RP·MIL
David Justice
89 META·1B·ATL
Fernando Valenzuela
79 META·SP·LAD
Bobby Witt Jr.
78 META·3B·KCR
Eloy Jimenez
75 META·LF·CHW
Bobby Abreu
73 META·LF·HOU
Joey Wendle
71 META·3B·TBR
Dontrelle Willis
68 META·SP·MIA
Yu Darvish
67 META·SP·TEX
56 cards · ranked by Meta Overall
Gary Sánchez
90 META·C·NYY
Jhoan Duran
88 META·RP·MIN
José Abreu
88 META·1B·CHW
Fernando Tatis Jr.
87 META·SS·SDP
Joe Mauer
87 META·C·MIN
Ronald Acuna Jr.
86 META·LF·ATL
Nolan Jones
86 META·3B·COL
Lou Gehrig
86 META·1B·NYY
Todd Helton
85 META·1B·COL
Patrick Wisdom
85 META·3B·CHC
33 cards · ranked by Meta Overall
Willie McCovey
92 META·1B·SFG
Ryan Howard
91 META·1B·PHI
Jason Bay
87 META·LF·PIT
Michael Harris II
86 META·LF·ATL
Keston Hiura
85 META·1B·MIL
Shohei Ohtani
84 META·LF·LAA
Miguel Andujar
82 META·1B·NYY
Yasmani Grandal
81 META·1B·SDP
Rafael Devers
80 META·1B·BOS
Francisco Lindor
78 META·3B·CLE
75 cards · ranked by Meta Overall
Jose Abreu
89 META·1B·CHW
Aristides Aquino
89 META·RF·CIN
Monte Irvin
86 META·1B·SFG
Minnie Minoso
80 META·3B·CHW
Garret Anderson
80 META·LF·LAA
Honus Wagner
79 META·2B·FA
Ryan O'Hearn
79 META·1B·KCR
Josh Bell
79 META·1B·PIT
Willie Mays
79 META·CF·SFG
Frank Thomas
77 META·1B·CHW
52 cards · ranked by Meta Overall
Todd Helton
87 META·1B·COL
Albert Pujols
84 META·LF·STL
Orlando Cepeda
83 META·1B·SFG
Chris Davis
81 META·1B·TEX
Eddie Murray
80 META·1B·BAL
Garret Anderson
80 META·LF·LAA
Evan Longoria
80 META·3B·TBR
Matt Adams
79 META·1B·STL
Honus Wagner
79 META·CF·FA
Ryan O'Hearn
79 META·1B·KCR
23 cards · ranked by Meta Overall
Mike Piazza
90 META·C·LAD
Ryan Braun
88 META·3B·MIL
Jackie Robinson
83 META·1B·LAD
Andre Dawson
80 META·CF·WSN
Wade Boggs
80 META·1B·BOS
Honus Wagner
79 META·CF·FA
Mickey Mantle
77 META·RF·NYY
Ted Williams
76 META·RF·BOS
Andrew McCutchen
74 META·CF·PIT
Craig Biggio
71 META·C·HOU
61 cards · ranked by Meta Overall
Lou Gehrig
85 META·1B·NYY
Jimmie Foxx
79 META·1B·OAK
Yoenis Cespedes
79 META·LF·OAK
Dellin Betances
78 META·RP·NYY
Trea Turner
77 META·CF·WSN
Yasiel Puig
77 META·RF·LAD
Ted Williams
77 META·RF·BOS
Paul Goldschmidt
76 META·1B·ARI
Rogers Hornsby
76 META·3B·STL
Randal Grichuk
74 META·LF·STL
10 cards · ranked by Meta Overall
Freddie Freeman
74 META·1B·ATL
Nolan Arenado
70 META·3B·COL
Jorge Posada
66 META·C·NYY
Jason Giambi
63 META·3B·OAK
Omar Vizquel
63 META·SS·SEA
Carson Smith
58 META·RP·SEA
Edinson Volquez
55 META·SP·CIN
Max Scherzer
51 META·SP·ARI
Phil Niekro
35 META·RP·ATL
Jose Ramirez
—·SS·CLE
Common questions about Rookie cards in MLB The Show.
