Annual All-Star Game

Cards honoring All-Star Game appearances and performances. Released around the All-Star Break with boosted ratings reflecting each player's peak All-Star season.

876 Cards·9 MLB The Show Years·Ranked by Meta Overall

Top Annual All-Star Game Cards · MLB The Show 26

49 cards · ranked by Meta Overall

See all 49

VIEW

#1

Roger Clemens

99 META·SP·HOU

VIEW

#2

Ken Griffey Jr.

98 META·CF·SEA

VIEW

#3

Steve Carlton

98 META·SP·PHI

VIEW

#4

Juan Soto

98 META·LF·NYY

VIEW

#5

Mike Piazza

98 META·C·LAD

VIEW

#6

Adley Rutschman

93 META·C·BAL

VIEW

#7

George Brett

92 META·1B·KCR

VIEW

#8

Eddie Murray

91 META·1B·BAL

VIEW

#9

Ken Griffey Jr.

91 META·CF·SEA

VIEW

#10

Joe Mauer

89 META·C·MIN

Top Annual All-Star Game Cards · MLB The Show 25

132 cards · ranked by Meta Overall

See all 132

VIEW

#1

Ketel Marte

116 META·2B·ARI

VIEW

#2

Kyle Schwarber

112 META·DH·PHI

VIEW

#3

Aaron Judge

111 META·LF·NYY

VIEW

#4

José Ramírez

108 META·3B·CLE

VIEW

#5

Will Smith

108 META·C·LAD

VIEW

#6

Kyle Schwarber

106 META·LF·PHI

VIEW

#7

Elly De La Cruz

106 META·3B·CIN

VIEW

#8

Shohei Ohtani

106 META·RF·LAD

VIEW

#9

Hunter Goodman

105 META·C·COL

VIEW

#10

Chipper Jones

105 META·3B·ATL

Top Annual All-Star Game Cards · MLB The Show 24

139 cards · ranked by Meta Overall

See all 139

VIEW

#1

Aaron Judge

117 META·RF·NYY

VIEW

#2

Fernando Tatis Jr.

113 META·2B·SDP

VIEW

#3

Jarren Duran

113 META·CF·BOS

VIEW

#4

Anthony Santander

112 META·1B·BAL

VIEW

#5

Juan Soto

111 META·RF·NYY

VIEW

#6

Shohei Ohtani

107 META·RF·LAD

VIEW

#7

David Fry

107 META·C·CLE

VIEW

#8

Ketel Marte

106 META·LF·ARI

VIEW

#9

Trea Turner

106 META·3B·PHI

VIEW

#10

Mike Trout

106 META·CF·LAA

Top Annual All-Star Game Cards · MLB The Show 23

152 cards · ranked by Meta Overall

See all 152

VIEW

#1

Adley Rutschman

126 META·C·BAL

VIEW

#2

Jose Ramirez

124 META·3B·CLE

VIEW

#3

Ronald Acuna Jr.

122 META·RF·ATL

VIEW

#4

Byron Buxton

120 META·CF·MIN

VIEW

#5

Ketel Marte

117 META·2B·ARI

VIEW

#6

Sean Murphy

115 META·C·ATL

VIEW

#7

Corbin Carroll

115 META·LF·ARI

VIEW

#8

Will Smith

115 META·C·LAD

VIEW

#9

Elias Diaz

114 META·C·COL

VIEW

#10

Mike Piazza

114 META·C·LAD

Top Annual All-Star Game Cards · MLB The Show 22

131 cards · ranked by Meta Overall

See all 131

VIEW

#1

Jackie Robinson

108 META·3B·LAD

VIEW

#2

Aaron Judge

108 META·CF·NYY

VIEW

#3

Byron Buxton

107 META·CF·MIN

VIEW

#4

Willson Contreras

105 META·C·CHC

VIEW

#5

Giancarlo Stanton

104 META·LF·NYY

VIEW

#6

Paul Goldschmidt

101 META·1B·STL

VIEW

#7

Dansby Swanson

101 META·3B·ATL

VIEW

#8

Andres Gimenez

101 META·2B·CLE

VIEW

#9

Manny Machado

101 META·1B·SDP

VIEW

#10

Alejandro Kirk

100 META·C·TOR

Top Annual All-Star Game Cards · MLB The Show 21

99 cards · ranked by Meta Overall

See all 99

VIEW

#1

Ronald Acuna Jr.

110 META·RF·ATL

VIEW

#2

Ozzie Albies

109 META·2B·ATL

VIEW

#3

Jacob deGrom

108 META·SP·NYM

VIEW

#4

Jose Ramirez

106 META·3B·CLE

VIEW

#5

Rafael Devers

106 META·3B·BOS

VIEW

#6

Cedric Mullins

106 META·CF·BAL

VIEW

#7

Salvador Perez

105 META·C·KCR

VIEW

#8

Trea Turner

105 META·SS·WSN

VIEW

#9

J.T. Realmuto

105 META·C·PHI

VIEW

#10

Aaron Judge

105 META·RF·NYY

Top Annual All-Star Game Cards · MLB The Show 20

28 cards · ranked by Meta Overall

See all 28

VIEW

#1

Miguel Cabrera

96 META·3B·DET

VIEW

#2

Rickey Henderson

93 META·CF·NYY

VIEW

#3

Fred McGriff

89 META·1B·ATL

VIEW

#4

Dwight Evans

89 META·RF·BOS

VIEW

#5

Willie McCovey

89 META·1B·SFG

VIEW

#6

Jeff Bagwell

89 META·1B·HOU

VIEW

#7

Roberto Alomar

88 META·2B·BAL

VIEW

#8

Tino Martinez

85 META·1B·NYY

VIEW

#9

Jackie Robinson

85 META·2B·LAD

VIEW

#10

Cliff Floyd

83 META·LF·MIA

Top Annual All-Star Game Cards · MLB The Show 19

105 cards · ranked by Meta Overall

See all 105

VIEW

#1

Pete Alonso

99 META·1B·NYM

VIEW

#2

Rich Gossage

98 META·CP·NYY

VIEW

#3

Joey Gallo

97 META·LF·TEX

VIEW

#4

Orlando Cepeda

94 META·1B·SFG

VIEW

#5

Jose Ramirez

94 META·3B·CLE

VIEW

#6

Max Muncy

93 META·2B·LAD

VIEW

#7

Joe Torre

93 META·C·ATL

VIEW

#8

Aroldis Chapman

92 META·CP·NYY

VIEW

#9

Matt Kemp

91 META·CF·LAD

VIEW

#10

Ronald Acuna Jr.

91 META·LF·ATL

Top Annual All-Star Game Cards · MLB The Show 18

41 cards · ranked by Meta Overall

See all 41

VIEW

#1

Aroldis Chapman

91 META·CP·CIN

VIEW

#2

Ralph Kiner

89 META·LF·PIT

VIEW

#3

David Wright

88 META·3B·NYM

VIEW

#4

Kenny Lofton

88 META·CF·CLE

VIEW

#5

Andrew McCutchen

87 META·CF·PIT

VIEW

#6

Jonathan Broxton

87 META·CP·LAD

VIEW

#7

Greg Holland

87 META·CP·KCR

VIEW

#8

Carlos Ruiz

86 META·C·PHI

VIEW

#9

Alan Trammell

86 META·SS·DET

VIEW

#10

Jose Bautista

86 META·RF·TOR

Frequently Asked Questions

Annual All-Star Game Cards

Common questions about Annual All-Star Game cards in MLB The Show.

By Meta Overall, the highest-rated Annual All-Star Game card on ShowZone is Adley Rutschman from MLB The Show 23 with a Meta Overall of 126 (BAL). You can compare every Annual All-Star Game card across all MLB The Show game years on this page, with each year showing the top 10 cards ranked by Meta Overall.

The top Annual All-Star Game card in MLB The Show 26 is Roger Clemens (HOU) with a Meta Overall of 99. The MLB The Show 26 section above shows the full top 10 list by Meta Overall, and the "See all" link opens every Annual All-Star Game card from that game year on the Players page.

ShowZone tracks 876 Annual All-Star Game cards across 9 MLB The Show game years. Every card released into Diamond Dynasty under this series is included, with ratings updated as roster updates land.

Annual All-Star Game has appeared in MLB The Show 26, MLB The Show 25, MLB The Show 24, MLB The Show 23, MLB The Show 22, MLB The Show 21, MLB The Show 20, MLB The Show 19, and MLB The Show 18. Each game year is its own banner on this page with the top 10 cards by Meta Overall, plus a "See all" link to view every card from that year on the Players page.

Top cards are ordered by Meta Overall — ShowZone's gameplay-weighted rating that factors in pitch quality, position weighting, and the current Diamond Dynasty competitive meta. It's a more accurate measure than the in-game OVR rating for ranked play. Each year banner shows the top 10 Annual All-Star Game cards for that MLB The Show release.

Top Annual All-Star Game Cards · MLB The Show 26

Top Annual All-Star Game Cards · MLB The Show 25

Top Annual All-Star Game Cards · MLB The Show 24

Top Annual All-Star Game Cards · MLB The Show 23

Top Annual All-Star Game Cards · MLB The Show 22

Top Annual All-Star Game Cards · MLB The Show 21

Top Annual All-Star Game Cards · MLB The Show 20

Top Annual All-Star Game Cards · MLB The Show 19

Top Annual All-Star Game Cards · MLB The Show 18

Annual All-Star Game Cards

What's the best Annual All-Star Game card in MLB The Show of all time?

What's the best Annual All-Star Game card in MLB The Show 26?

How many Annual All-Star Game cards are there in MLB The Show?

What years does Annual All-Star Game appear in MLB The Show?

How are top Annual All-Star Game cards ranked on ShowZone?